Is the Pioneer DJM-S9 perfect? Our review covers the mixer’s key flaw—faceplate paint chipping—and details the benefits and challenges of custom faceplate upgrades, giving DJs insights on durability, installation, and long-term value.

Pioneer DJM-S9 Custom Faceplate Upgrade Review: Fixing the Industry Standard Scratcher’s Mixer

The Pioneer DJM-S9 has become the leading mixer for scratch DJs around the world. Its tactile controls, sound quality, and tight Serato integration make it the choice for professionals and enthusiasts alike. But no mixer is flawless, and S9 owners are all too familiar with a key issue: faceplate paint chipping. We review the standard DJM-S9, dive into its common flaw, and evaluate whether custom faceplate upgrades truly solve the problem.

The DJM-S9: Top-Notch Features, One Main Issue

The DJM-S9 shines with:

• Rugged construction tailored for turntablism
• Responsive faders and EQs designed for high-speed scratching
• Intuitive effects pads and buttons built for creative mixing
• Seamless Serato DJ compatibility

Despite its $1,700 price tag (typical for flagship mixers), frequent use exposes a significant cosmetic flaw: faceplate paint wears off quickly with regular scratching. Owning a premium mixer should mean enjoying durability and pride in appearance, but daily practice takes its toll.

The Problem: Paint Fading and Chipping

Among scratch DJs, the DJM-S9’s faceplate often shows visible signs of wear—chipped paint and fading, especially around the crossfader and EQ areas. This is more than a cosmetic complaint. For high-end equipment, buyers expect strength and long-lasting finish.

The Solution: Custom Aftermarket Faceplates

To address the frustration, DJs turn to custom faceplate manufacturers. One standout is “Cutter Face Records,” offering tailor-made S9 faceplates built from solid metal and finished with laser-etched artwork for improved durability.

Differences from OEM Pioneer Faceplate

• Material: Custom faceplates use denser metals for greater sturdiness.
• Finish: Laser-etched artwork creates a tactile, scratch-resistant design.
• Customization: No Serato or Pioneer branding for a minimalist, cleaner look.

Feeling the difference is immediate—aftermarket faceplates feel substantial, with deep-set graphics that resist wear.

The Installation Process: Expect a Challenge

Installing a custom faceplate is not trivial:

• Removing fader caps and knobs is routine for experienced DJs.
• Detaching dust guards and plastic components is more complex; aftermarket fitment may require sanding and trimming for a perfect fit.
• Custom faceplates, especially those manufactured outside major brands (e.g., from Russia), may need additional work for alignment.

If you’re patient and willing to “go through hell” for long-term durability and style, the upgrade is worth the effort.

Price and Delivery: Is It Worth It?

Custom faceplates often cost around $131 plus shipping, with long lead times (up to a month from order to delivery). Consider this investment against the stress of paint chips, repeated replacements, and pride in a mixer that looks as good as it performs.

Pros and Cons of Custom Faceplates

Pros:

• Paint and finish do not fade or chip
• Unique style, tailored appearance
• Tactile metal feel vs. fragile plastic or standard coating

Cons:

• Expensive compared to stickers or skins
• Challenging installation—may require modification
• Longer delivery times and custom fitment issues

Alternatives: Skins and Stickers

Cheaper options like vinyl skins or stickers offer temporary solutions but lack the sturdy, premium feel of a metal faceplate. For scratch DJs who want durability and a lasting upgrade, full replacement is preferable.

Final Verdict: Should You Upgrade Your DJM-S9 Faceplate?

If you use your DJM-S9 daily and take pride in both performance and appearance, investing in a custom faceplate is advisable. You’ll benefit from:

• Enhanced durability
• Distinctive style
• The satisfaction of a mixer built to endure intense scratching

Just be prepared for installation challenges and extra cost. If you value quality and want a mixer that stays looking sharp, custom faceplates deliver.

Key Takeaways

• DJM-S9’s main cosmetic flaw is paint chipping after heavy use
• Custom faceplates fix this permanently but require patience, money, and manual skill
• Metal or laser-etched aftermarket options provide superior look and feel compared to factory or vinyl solutions
• Installation can be tough, but results speak for themselves

If you’re serious about your craft and mixer aesthetics, upgrading your faceplate may be the best investment you make in your DJ gear.